Senators’ official cars lawsuit, efforts in futility – Adeyeye


Nigerian Senate has described the legal action by some civil society groups against its plan to purchase official cars for members, as an effort in futility.
The Senate Spokesperson, Adedayo Adeyeye, stated this during an interview on Channel Television on Sunday night while reacting to the alleged N5.5bn earmarked for the purchase of the exotic cars.
The Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project , BudgIT, Enough is Enough and 6,721 concerned Nigerians last week filed a lawsuit against the Senate leadership asking the Federal High Court to restrain, prevent and stop the National Assembly Service Commission from paying or releasing the sum of N5.550bn budgeted for purchase of luxury cars for principal members of the ninth Senate.
The Civil Society groups are also asking the Court to restrain and stop the Senate from collecting the money until the downward review of the amount proposed by the Senate.
But Adeyeye, who dismissed the report of the N5.5bn cars for lawmakers, said the amount would only be legal if budgeted by the National Assembly for such purpose.
The Senator said he was not aware of any plan to purchase vehicles for the lawmakers with such a huge amount.
He said, “It (planned legal battle) is an exercise in futility; a complete exercise in futility. Even I as a Senator have not heard anything about that.
“So why will people be relying on rumour and newspaper reports? I wouldn’t know and in any case, if the Senate is going to spend that (amount); if it is budgeted for, then it means it is purely legal.”
The Senate spokesperson noted that every new administration budgets vehicles for public office holders.
He lamented the public outcry against the development in the Senate, noting that it’s a norm for the three tiers of government.
He said, “So why will the National Assembly be different? Why are they focusing on the National Assembly and not looking at the Executive, Judiciary arms of government?
“All of these people are entitled to official cars and do use official cars.
“Directors of agencies, even minor officials in agencies use official cars. So why will the National Assembly be different?
“Why should it be a problem that the National Assembly is entitled to cars, to use official cars?”
He wondered why the purchase of cars for senators was viewed from the negative perspective.
Adeyeye said he could not imagine himself in a vehicle used by a former member.
He said, “Some of the vehicles they bought four years ago were no longer serviceable while others have probably been sold to their users.
“The mischief makers should desist from attempting to destroy the National Assembly, because doing so would amount to destroying the nation’s democratic process,” he added.
The lawsuit, filed by Kolawole Oluwadare and supported by an affidavit of urgency, was marked FHC/L/CS/1511/2019 and filed on Friday at the Federal High Court, Ikoyi Lagos.
The plaintiffs argued that, “Spending a huge sum of N5.550 billion to buy luxury cars for principal members of the ninth Senate is unjust and unfair.”
They said, “It negates the constitutional oath of office made by members to perform their functions in the interest of the well-being and prosperity of Nigeria and its citizens, as contained in the Seventh Schedule of the 1999 Nigerian Constitution (as amended).”
The plaintiffs further argued that, “the proposed spending by the 9th Senate raises pertinent questions: What is the economic value and contribution of the vehicles sought to be purchased to the grand scheme of Nigeria’s economy?
“What are the parameters used to arrive at cost efficiency and value for money in the decision to purchase the vehicles? Where are the vehicles purchased by the eighth Senate?”
The 6,721 concerned Nigerians who joined the suit as co-plaintiffs with SERAP, BudgIT and EiE include: Bring Back Our Girls’ co-conveners, Oby Ezekwesili and Aisha Yesufu; Jibrin Ibrahim; Edetaen Ojo; Abiola Akiyode-Afolabi, and Deji Adeyanju.
The plaintiffs said, “The failure or refusal by the Senate to comply with legal and constitutional provisions is nothing but an act of arbitrariness.
“The money could be better allocated to more important sectors of the National Assembly expenditure – like constituency projects and National Assembly-endowed educational scholarships


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here